If you really wanted to impact rep system, it would have to take on a HF style implementation.
Meaning contracts, as for new users and greynames they don't understand the current state of rep inflation.
And the vouch button is so small, and only applicable to threads. This makes it much much harder to gain vouches even if you aquire a lot of sales.
Vouches in my eyes are more valuable to knowledgeable users because they are much harder to get, but for the average buyer they wouldn't even know the difference as someone can make thousands $ in sales and not even have a vouch on their thread, as you basically have to directly instruct someone on the vouch button or else it's basically invisible in the current system.
Just my small opinion. I do give out rep to users I don't particularly know very well, a lot of time its just for small interactions in shoutbox.
But in the large scheme of things my +24 or whatever is nothing to an inflated 700 rep user who hasn't really even sold anything before.
But this is basically how the whole rep system works for every single user.
MY PGP
VERIFY MY IDENTITY BEFORE DOING BUSINESS